When looking for new bulbs such as LED bulbs, everyone wants to know “What’s the brightest bulb?” Well to answer that question and to truly get a better picture of what “brightness” is, we need to get scientific and define a few terms. But not to worry! I’m going to make this article as simple as possible to wrap your head around. So stick with me for a moment and you’ll be a pro when it comes to figuring out and understand true brightness.
The two main words to define as we talk about headlight brightness are lumen and lux.
Lumen: A unit of measurement for luminous flux which is a measure of the total quantity of visible light emitted by a source.
Lux: A unit of measurement for illuminance which is a measure of how much luminous flux is spread out over a given area.
“One can think of luminous flux (measured in lumens) as a measure of the total “amount” of visible light present, and the illuminance (measured in lux) as a measure of the intensity of illumination on a surface at a particular distance from the source.”
So let’s think about these definitions as we see how lumen and lux amounts are measured and how that process applies to bulbs.
Integrating sphere used to measure lumen.
Luminous flux, which I’ll just refer to as lumen, is measured inside of a device called an integrating sphere. A bulb is placed inside the sphere and the light given off by the bulb is scattered by the interior of the integrating sphere and evenly distributed over all angles. The total lumen amount of a light source can be measured accurately since light can be captured from all angles from inside the sphere. While this method of measuring the brightness of a bulb works well for lighting applications where 360 degrees of light is needed, (such as a table lamp) the lumen amount is only half of the story while testing the brightness of headlight bulbs. This is why illuminance and lux are so important.
Lux is measured by installing the bulb inside a housing and testing to see how well the lumen amounts are projected or reflected out from the housing. In this instance, we measured the beam pattern created from the housing and bulb combination on a wall 25 feet away. From this distance and this position, we are able to see the lumen amounts from the bulb that are truly being utilized and turned into a usable beam pattern by the headlight housing. When measuring lux this way, we are able to take into account multiple factors playing into the brightness of the bulb and find a clearer picture of true, usable light. The lumen amount from the bulb, the relationship between bulb and housing, the resulting beam pattern, and distance are all factors when calculating lux this way.
A digital light meter used to measure lux. In this application, lux is being measured in a beam pattern created by a LED bulb inside a headlight housing.
So you’re probably thinking, “Well then, doesn’t that mean a bulb with the highest lumen amount will be the brightest?” Maybe. Remember, lumen amounts are only one piece of the puzzle when determining usable light brightness.
It is possible for a bulb with high lumen amounts to focus poorly once placed inside a headlight housing due to poor engineering and design. The result would be an unfocused beam pattern with light reflected or projected poorly. In that case, a poorly focused beam pattern from a bulb with an initially high lumen amount would have low lux measurements because the light is spread out or unfocused. A light like this would be “bright” on paper, but not actually usable in a real-world scenario. Below we see an example similar to this scenario in a 2007-2013 Toyota Tundra housing. Two LED bulbs were tested here along with the stock bulb, but take a look at the beam patterns and lux numbers.
Original equipment halogen bulbs typically emit 900-1,000 lumen, and this stock bulb was measured at 530 lux at 25 feet with this housing. The GTR Lighting GEN 2 LED bulb emits 3,600 lumens and was measured at 360 lux at 25 feet inside this housing. That LED bulb in that housing actually produced less lux than the stock bulb even though it has 3-times the lumen. The difference can be seen when comparing the two beam patterns. The additional lumen amounts are not focused as precisely within this Tundra housing as the stock bulbs are. The result is a beam pattern less concentrated and arguably less bright.
Now compare the two LED bulbs. The GTR Lighting GEN 2 bulb emits 3,600 lumens and was measured at 360 lux at 25 feet inside this housing. Whereas the GTR Lighting GEN 3 bulb emits 3,700 lumens (only 100 more) and was measured at 1,360 lux at 25 feet inside this housing. This bulb is emitting high lumen amounts and high lux amounts inside this housing. Take a look at the beam patterns and you’ll see why. This LED bulb is capable of producing a beam pattern that is more concentrated versus the other LED bulb, and more closely matches the stock bulb beam pattern. And this increase of 1,000 lux is achieved by only a 100-lumen increase in light output. This is achieved through a better-designed bulb that interacts with the housing much like a stock halogen bulb would.
All that to say, when comparing the brightness of bulbs, make sure to look at the big picture. With LED bulbs especially, make sure you take into account the beam pattern the LED bulb creates when placed inside a housing. Look at more than just the advertised lumen amounts–if the manufacturer gives lux numbers look for those too. Also, see how the bulb itself is designed and look for bulbs that more closely fit the profile and dimensions of a stock halogen bulb.